Greeks called on to vote on the future of their country–but what is the question?

As you may have read, the Greek government dropped a sudden bombshell on the debt negotiations this weekend, announcing plans for a citizen referendum next Sunday on the deal offered by the Eurozone leadership. The problem though, it seems, is that no one really knows what exactly is the question and what exactly their “Yes” or “No” vote would actually mean.

I heard this exchange on the radio this morning between a news commentator and a member of the governing Syriza party, who is urging voters to vote “No,” i.e., rejecting the deal offered by the Eurozone:

Commentator: You have said that a No vote does not mean voting to leave the Euro, is that correct?

Syriza Rep: Yes, it is a vote to reject the deal. It is not a referendum on the Euro.

Commentator: But if we vote “No” and reject the deal, how can we possibly stay in the Euro?

Syriza Rep: We negotiate and try to get a better deal than the one we are rejecting.

Commentator: Negotiate with whom? THERE WON’T BE ANYONE TO NEGOTIATE WITH! The Eurozone leadership has made this clear–the game is over!

Syriza Rep: We don’t know that. We aren’t voting on the Euro, we’re just voting on this deal…

 

And around and around they go. So, the bottom line is that the government is urging people to vote “No” but is maintaining the illusion that this does not mean voting for leaving the Euro. Public opinion polls have consistently shown majority support for staying in the Euro, so how the question is presented to voters is critical.

Most interestingly, Finance Minister Yannis Varoufakis’s comments after the weekend’s Eurogroup meetings seemed to me to hint that the Syriza party’s strategy was to call for a “No” vote, thereby avoiding political responsibility for yet another lousy austerity deal, but actually expecting and hoping that a majority of the Greek people would vote “Yes,” thereby keeping Greece in the Eurozone and buying some more time to work for a better deal in the future. Check out his statement at http://yanisvaroufakis.eu/2015/06/28/as-it-happened-yanis-varoufakis-intervention-during-the-27th-june-2015-eurogroup-meeting/.  Particularly his conclusion:

“Colleagues, refusing to extend the loan agreement for a few weeks, and for the purpose of giving the Greek people an opportunity to deliberate in peace and quiet on the institutions’ proposal, especially given the high probability that they will accept these proposals (contrary to our government’s advice), will damage permanently the credibility of the Eurogroup as a democratic decision making body comprising partner states sharing not only a common currency but also common values.”

Incidentally, I think Varoufakis makes a very compelling case that the Eurogroup acted not only overly harshly towards Greece  with this decision, but also in a way that is likely to damage their own cause. Many Greeks will be more likely now, I expect, to vote “No” in the referendum because they feel that this decision not to allow one more week of funding to Greece in order to let them hold a democratic referendum is just one final kick in the teeth to Greek self-determination.

Uncharted waters and scary times ahead, no matter what the result of Sunday’s referendum.

Advertisements

5 comments

    1. Thanks Sharon for passing on the Diane Rehm link. I will check it out. My family all headed out the day before the bank closures so were unaffected. Foreign debit cards are NOT supposed to be affected by the withdrawal limits but I wouldn’t want to bet on there being sufficient cash in the ATM’s until we see how things play out in the coming weeks.

      Like

    1. I listen to the radio a lot so my comprehension of the vocabulary around the one topic of conversation that is ever heard these days on radio–debt negotiations, referendum, bailout, etc.–is pretty good. Just don’t ask me to carry out an intelligent conversation about normal daily life…

      Like

  1. Well Tom it is certainly an interesting game from the out side. I can see how the Greek people are fed up with the Northern Europeans telling them what to do. After all Greece is the cradle of democracy. It seems that Puerto Rico is now moving down the same path. Following Argentina a decade ago. It seems that declaring bankruptcy is not an option. But telling them to stuff it is. It sound like a Greek vacation may be a great deal in the next few months. Glad you made it back into the country. As a resident alien here I also have trouble getting through LA each time I return. It seem my finger prints have worn off and that really concerns them. Plus my 54 year old arrest record for loitering around a school at a late and unreasonable hour is still on the record. Bad stuff. That is a real cause for concern. My American wife has died so I have nothing to fall back on except my American paratrooper tattoo on my right bicep and unfortunately it is fading badly after 50 years. I may have to get it touched up. Keep us posted life will go on.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s